Friday, January 23, 2009
« Idiot spammer | Main | DSLs – fun, cool, but maybe a bad ... »

One of my kid’s machines just died – hard drive crash. In the past, this has been a pain, because I’d have to reinstall the OS (including finding and installing all the drivers) and he’d have to reinstall all his games, find the keys, all that stuff. It could literally take days or weeks to get the computer back to normal.

However, a few months ago I picked up the HP Windows Home Server appliance. It does regular (at least weekly, if not daily) automatic image backups of all the machines in my house. I bought it because a couple colleagues of mine had machines crash and they were singing the praises of WHS in terms of getting themselves back online quickly and easily.

I am now officially joining the chorus!

Here’s what I did: Pop out the bad hard drive, and put in an empty new one. Boot off the system rescue CD, walk through a simple wizard, wait 90 minutes for the restore and that’s it – he’s totally up and running as though nothing happened. Better actually, because this new hard drive is 3x bigger than the original – WHS simply restored to the new, bigger, drive without a complaint.

I guess it can be a little more complex with nonstandard network or hard drive drivers (How to restore a PC from a WHS after hard drive fails), but even that doesn’t look too bad. But in my case, WHS found the hard drive and network card automatically, so it was a total no-brainer.

The thing is, I’m not used to computers acting like or being like an appliance. But the HP WHS box really is an appliance – the kind of thing a regular home user could install. The machine comes with a fold-out instruction poster. 6 steps to install (things like “plug in power”, “plug in network”, “push on button”, etc). And it does these automatic backups, in a way where it deals with increasing volumes of data by warning you BEFORE the server runs out of space (unlike Vista’s built-in backup, which is terrible).

Start running out of space? Just pop in a new hard drive – without even shutting down the server. I’ve added two since I got the box. All PCs should work this way!!

The backups appear to be very smart. I’m backing up numerous machines, and the total backups are using less space than if you add all the backed up content together. I assume they are using compression, but I also think they are doing smart things like not backing up Windows XP and Vista each time, because those are the same across numerous machines. As are many of the games played by I and my kids.

What’s even better, is that WHS does video and audio streaming. I’ve been putting all our media on the box, and watching it from the xbox or media PC in other rooms.

There are more features, but I don’t want to sound like a spec sheet.

The point is that I’ve been entirely impressed by the simplicity and consumer-friendliness of this product since I took it out of the box (did I mention it is a really nice-looking mini-tower?). The fact that the computer restore feature works exactly as advertised is just further confirmation that it was a great purchase.

I seriously think that every home that has one or more computers with any data that shouldn’t be lost needs a WHS. Yes, that probably means you! ;)

Friday, January 23, 2009 3:35:40 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)  #    Disclaimer  |  Comments [7]  | 
Saturday, January 24, 2009 8:04:02 AM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
Sounds like a great product and a great idea. I had been using a windows xp pro box to get to do that since last four years[no keyboard, no mouse, no monitor, just a the tower with a network cable and power]. I could shut it down and start it up whenever I needed a backup. Since windows xp pro comes with a built in router[not advertized by microsoft for some reason] its no problem.

However I got a virus last year, and changed it to a linux machine. That way viruses can hit my windows vista laptop, but at least the file store wont get damaged. Of course windows home server is much more stronger then windows xp pro and personally for a non technical user, getting linux to do that would takes a couple of hours.
Saturday, January 24, 2009 10:44:15 AM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
Hi Rocky,

Same story here. Last year my daughters laptop died too... I completely agree with you that it is a great product! The idea that every computer in the house is backupped automatically is great.

Best,

Andre Obelink, MVP
Monday, January 26, 2009 1:33:39 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
I have one too and it is indeed nice. I've only restored one PC, and it worked great.

The low-volume backups are achieved by backing up disk blocks rather than files. Whenever two blocks are the same (which occurs often between 2 Windows PCs), a pointer to the existing backed up block is stored. I don't know how or if it tracks the references, i.e. does it keep reference-counts like COM, or is it garbage-collected like .NET?
Tuesday, January 27, 2009 2:44:14 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
U r so correct about getting in on the chorus line, though I am surprised that you of all people are not singing the praises of the API's in the appliance. There are so many things you can layer on the platform, SIP, VoIP, Virtualization, Home Automation, Home Instrumentation (Power grid, security relays, air quality (mold checks), etc...). U got the religion now start writing the apps ;). Oh, but one down side, ya need to figure out how to do a quick system restore from a post installation/configuration state. It does not seem to back its system state up and thus there is no obvious way to recover the server (at least that is what I am reading).

Cheers...
Tuesday, January 27, 2009 9:27:05 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
I have a full-blown Windows server for running my apps, so I haven't felt the need to explore programming WHS. My goal in getting WHS was to have a good backup strategy for my desktop and laptop computers, and as a bonus I get the very valuable media streaming features.

But I view this like I do a TiVo box - as an appliance that had better just work without me needing to tweak or tamper with it.

It is like investments - you put some money in risky positions, but have a base in something conservative and safe. Same with home technology - I have my risky play areas, but I want backups and TV viewing to be safe, reliable and easy :)
Friday, January 30, 2009 12:15:30 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
With regards to your comment about efficient use of space for backups, I believe WHS uses a technology called "Single Instance Storage" that ensures that a given file (no matter what computer it came from) will only be backed up once.

I just got a WHS and so far I'm pretty happy with it. No catastrophic failures yet, but I'm almost looking forward to seeing WHS in action. (Wait... *knock on wood*, I'm not really).
Jeremy Wiebe
Monday, February 02, 2009 10:38:47 PM (Central Standard Time, UTC-06:00)
I've had it for almost a year now and it's been instrumental - almost as much so as CSLA is at work :). The server back-up feature they added in the last SP was great. I got 1 tower, and 3 lap tops being backed up on it along with several family who are using the shared folders through the web site (which is great for sharing photos of the kids).

I just got the software, not the tower+software so my only machine I upgrade and the install didn't give me too much headaches - I have to load the network driver first - but simple.

Worth every penny.
Brian
Comments are closed.